Search

Leave a Message

Thank you for your message. I will be in touch with you shortly.

Browse Homes

Is It Better To Rent or Buy a Home?

Beth Helvey June 2, 2025

You’ve probably asked yourself lately: Is it even worth trying to buy a home right now?

With high home prices and stubborn mortgage rates, renting can seem like the safer choice right now. Or maybe your only choice. That’s a very real feeling. And perhaps buying today isn’t your best move; it’s not for everyone right away. You should only buy a home when you’re ready and able to do it, and if the timing is right for you.

But here’s the thing you need to know about renting.

While it may feel like a safer bet today – and in some areas might even be less expensive month-to-month than owning – it can really cost you more over time.

In fact, a recent Bank of America survey found that 70% of aspiring homeowners worry about what long-term renting means for their future. And they’re not wrong.

Owning a home may seem way out of reach, but if you make a plan now and steadily work toward it, homeownership comes with serious long-term financial benefits.

Homeownership Builds Wealth Over Time

Buying a home isn’t just about having a place to live – it’s a step toward building your future wealth.

Why? Home prices typically rise over time, which means the longer you wait, the more expensive it is to buy. And even in some markets where home prices are softening today, the overall long-term trend speaks for itself (see graph below):

a graph of a price of houses sold in the united statesAnd as home values rise, so does your equity when you’re a homeowner. That’s the difference between what your home is worth and what you owe. So, with every mortgage payment, that equity grows. Over time, that becomes part of your net worth.

Today, the average homeowner’s net worth is nearly 40X greater than that of a renter. That’s a shocking difference, and the dollars in the visual below don’t lie (see graph below):

a green rectangle with white textAnd it’s one of the big reasons why Forbes says:

“While renting might seem like [the] less stressful option . . . owning a home is still a cornerstone of the American dream and a proven strategy for building long-term wealth.”

The Biggest Downside of Renting

So, short-term, why does renting feel like a simpler choice? Lower monthly payments, less responsibility, no strings attached. But long-term? It can sting.

For decades, while home prices have been rising, rent has gone up too. And while rent has held rather steady more recently, history shows the overall trend is up and to the right. That makes saving for a home more complicated than ever (see graph below):

a graph of a number of peopleThat kind of financial uncertainty has a real impact. In the same Bank of America survey, 72% of potential buyers said they worry rising rent could affect their current and long-term finances.

Because rent doesn’t build wealth. It doesn’t come back to you later. It pays your landlord’s mortgage – not yours.

So, whether you rent or own, you’re paying a mortgage. The question is: whose mortgage do you want to pay?

Renting vs. Buying: What Really Matters

Think of it this way. Renting means your money is gone once you pay it. Owning means your payment builds equity – like a savings account you can live in. Sure, buying comes with responsibility. But it also comes with the kind of reward that grows over time. And that’s why you need a solid plan to get there.

As Joel Berner, Senior Economist at Realtor.com, explains:

“Households working on their budget will find it much easier to continue to rent than to go through the expenses of homeownership. However, they need to consider the equity and generational wealth they can build up by owning a home that they can’t by renting it. In the long run, buying a home may be a better investment even if the short-run costs seem prohibitive.”

Bottom Line

Renting may feel more do-able today. But over time, it could cost you more – without helping you build anything for your future.

If homeownership feels out of reach today, you’re not alone. And the first step toward getting out of the rental trap is to set a plan. Let’s connect, set your specific goals, and explore your options – so you’re ready when the time is right.

Florida Real Estate Blog

Why Buying Real Estate Is Still the Best Long-Term Investment

Newly Built Homes May Be Less Expensive Than You Think

Is It Better To Rent or Buy a Home?

Savor Sarasota

6 Surprising Professions That Unlock Special Mortgage Perks Despite Student Debt

Common Real Estate Terms Explained

More Homes for Sale Isn’t a Warning Sign – It's Your Buying Opportunity

Thinking about an Adjustable-Rate Mortgage? Read This First.

April 2025 Real Estate Market Report: Trends in Sarasota and Manatee Counties

Looking for fun things to do Memorial Day weekend May 24-27? Top 5 events in Sarasota area

Siesta Beach Named to ‘World’s 50 Best Beaches’ List

The Social Shift That Could Turn Renters Into Future Homeowners

You Could Use Some of Your Equity To Give Your Children the Gift of Home

Why Waiting for 3% Rates to Come Back Around Could Cost You as a Homebuyer

Home Projects That Boost Value

13 Kitchen Remodel Mistakes to Avoid According to Professional Designers

Barrier Island Hotels Reopen After Last Fall’s Storms

Housing Market Forecasts for the Second Half of the Year

The Beauty and Resilience of Florida-Friendly Gardens

If You’re Selling Your Home Soon, Don’t Let the Word ‘Concession’ Scare You

9 Quaint Towns Straight Out of a Disney Movie

Sarasota’s Pro Soccer Team Is Leveling Up

How to Know if a “Delayed” or “Exclusive” Listing Is Right for You

What an Economic Slowdown Could Mean for the Housing Market

A Tale of Two Housing Markets

Mote Reports First Local Sea Turtle Nests of 2025 Season

May 1st is the First Official Day of Turtle Nest Season

Why Today’s Foreclosure Numbers Aren’t a Warning Sign

Paused Your Moving Plans? Here’s Why It’s Time To Hit Play Again

23 Biggest Interior Design Regrets, According to Influencers and Tastemakers

March 2025 Real Estate Market Report: Trends in Sarasota and Manatee Counties

Should I Buy a Home Now or Wait?

What You Can Do When Mortgage Rates Are a Moving Target

Does Your Current Home Fit Your Retirement Plans?

Pre-Approval Isn’t Commitment – It’s Clarity

Could Your Social Media Profile Be Hurting Your Chances of Getting a Mortgage?

These 8 Real Structures Inspired the Castles in Disney Films

Are You Saving Up To Buy a Home? Your Tax Refund Can Help

8 Ways to Size Up a Neighborhood Before You Buy a House There

5 Hidden Costs of House Hunting—Sneaky Little Expenses You Didn’t See Coming (But Totally Will)

Why You Don't Want To Skip Your Home Inspection

Seriously, Don't Skip It

The Truth About Newly Built Homes and Today’s Market

The #1 Thing Sellers Need To Know About Their Asking Price

Are “ADUs” Your Ticket to Smaller, More Affordable Housing?

Or to Start Your Income Property Journey?

Housing Market Panic?

Why You Shouldn’t Believe Every Headline (Or Chart) You See Online

Townhomes: A Smart Solution for Today’s First-Time Buyers

Selling Your First Home?

Here’s How Thinking Like a First-Time Buyer Can Help

A New Hotel Has Opened on Lido Key

Cirque St. Armands Beachside has replaced Lido Key’s Holiday Inn—and it’s a major upgrade.

Buyers Have More Negotiation Power

Here’s How To Use It

Why Pre-Approval Is More Important Than Ever

February 2025 Real Estate Market Report

Trends in Sarasota and Manatee Counties

Tiny Issues, Big Turn-Offs for Buyers

10 Small Fixes That Can Make or Break the Sale of Your Home

How Buying or Selling a Home Helps Your Local Economy

What You Need To Know About Homeowner’s Insurance

Planning Ahead: Putting Aside Money for Home Upkeep

What You Need to Know About Pre-Approval

Factors That Can Affect Your Preapproval

Is the Housing Market Starting To Balance Out?

It Is in Sarasota!

Selling Your Home? Here's Why More Deals Are Falling Apart

And How to Keep Yours on Track

Do You Know How Much Your Home Is Worth?

You May Want to Find Out.

Headed Back Into the Office?

You May Decide to Move

Sarasota Broke Rainfall Records

Sarasota just witnessed an extraordinary rainfall event yesterday, one for the record books.

A modern dining room with a black table and chairs. A vase with plants sits in the center of the table.
Ohana, on Longboat Key, Has Sold for $19.75 Million Cash

It’s probably part of why it fetched such a high price, setting a new record for tony Longboat Key.

Your Equity Could Make a Move Possible To Sarasota

Many homeowners looking to sell feel like they’re stuck between a rock and a hard place right now.

A modern kitchen with dark blue cabinets, a large marble countertop
Are You Ready For Hurricane Season in Sarasota?

Hurricane season started in Florida a few days ago and runs through November.

Work With Beth

I’d love to hear from you! Whether you’re buying, selling, or just exploring your options, I'm here to provide answers, insights, and the support you need. Contact me and start planning your next move.