Beth Helvey November 18, 2026
If you've scrolled through the news lately, you've probably seen headlines warning about foreclosures and short sales creeping back into the market. It's an easy story to tell, and it gets clicks. But when you actually look at the local numbers for Sarasota and Manatee counties this October, the real story is a lot less dramatic, and honestly, a lot more interesting.
Here's what's actually happening.
Sales held fairly steady in October, but the market got more layered. Cash buyers played a bigger role, financed buyers pulled back a little, and activity shifted around by price point. Condos and townhomes kept growing, luxury sales picked up in Sarasota, and Manatee saw more action at the more affordable end. Meanwhile, homes kept moving to contract faster than a year ago, and sellers kept more of their original asking price.
As RASM President David Crawford put it, buyers and sellers are experiencing different conditions depending on property type, price point, and whether a purchase is financed. That's really the headline this month: the averages can look calm, but underneath them, things are shifting in ways worth paying attention to.
In Sarasota County, 633 single-family homes sold in October, down about 5% from a year ago. But don't let that dip fool you. The median sale price jumped 10% to $490,000, and homes are moving fast, a median of just 40 days to go under contract, down from 61 days last year.
What's really going on here is a shift in what's selling. Sales under $400,000 dropped nearly 20%, while sales of $1 million or more jumped over 25%. So it's not that fewer people want to buy, it's that the mix of homes selling has tilted toward the higher end, which pulls the median and average price up with it.
Inventory also tightened, down over 14%, bringing supply down to 4 months.
In Manatee County, single-family sales actually ticked up slightly, to 601 homes. The median price rose almost 4% to $499,000. Interestingly, Manatee was the only major segment in the whole report where inventory went up instead of down, rising about 1%. Even so, supply remains tight at just over 4 months. Homes went under contract in a median of 49 days, down from 55 a year ago.
Like Sarasota, Manatee saw fewer sales under $400,000 (down nearly 11%) and more sales at $1 million and up (up over 18%).
Condos and townhomes kept doing what they've been doing all year: outperforming.
In Sarasota County, condo and townhome sales rose over 9% to 269 closed sales. The median price climbed almost 5% to $325,000. The average price jumped a striking 64%, but that's a mix effect, not a sign that every condo suddenly got more expensive. Sales of $1 million or more more than doubled, from 16 to 36 transactions, and the county even saw nine sales of $5 million or more, including three north of $10 million. Those headline-grabbing luxury deals pull the average way up, while the median gives you a much more honest read on what a typical condo buyer is actually paying.
In Manatee County, condo and townhome sales rose over 13% to 198 transactions, and the median price held fairly flat at $295,000. Here the story is almost the opposite of Sarasota's. Most of Manatee's growth came from sales under $500,000, which jumped from 158 to 177 transactions. Two counties, two very different condo markets, both growing, just from different directions.
This is the part worth sitting with for a second, because it's where the headlines and the actual data really part ways.
Across Sarasota and Manatee combined, single-family home sales broke down like this in October: 1,220 traditional sales, 9 foreclosures, and 5 short sales. For condos and townhomes: 462 traditional sales, 4 foreclosures, and 1 short sale.
Add it up, and distressed sales, foreclosures and short sales combined, made up about 1% of all closed sales in the region this month. Not 10%. Not a wave. About one in a hundred.
Yes, the raw percentage changes can look alarming in a headline. Sarasota's single-family short sales, for example, went from 1 to 3 year-over-year, which sounds like a 200% increase. But three total sales out of hundreds is a rounding error, not a trend. The same goes for small moves in foreclosure counts across both counties. When your starting number is tiny, small changes produce big-sounding percentages that don't actually mean much in practice.
The bottom line: this remains overwhelmingly a traditional sale market. Homeowners are selling because they want to, not because they're being forced to, and that's a meaningfully different market than the one headlines sometimes suggest.
If you're thinking about buying: homes are moving faster than they were a year ago, and sellers are holding onto more of their asking price, especially in the segments you're likely shopping in. If you've been waiting for the market to soften before jumping in, the data suggests that window may be narrowing rather than widening. Now is the time to get serious and find out what's actually possible for you.
If you're thinking about selling: you're in a good position, particularly if your home fits current buyer demand at your price point. Pricing it to reflect what's actually happening in your specific neighborhood and property type matters more than ever, since this market has gotten more segmented, not less.
And for everyone: don't let distressed-sale headlines spook you into thinking this market is in trouble. The data says otherwise. Foreclosures and short sales remain a very small slice of what's actually selling.
As always, these are countywide numbers, and what's happening on your street or in your building can tell a different story. That's exactly where I can help.
Reach out and let's talk about your specific situation. Whether you're buying, selling, or just want someone to make sense of what these numbers mean for your neighborhood, I'm here for it.
Beth Helvey 📞 941.330.3600 ✉️ [email protected]
Data compiled by Florida Realtors® from Stellar MLS, reflecting closed and pending transactions in Sarasota and Manatee counties for October 2026.
Sarasota Real Estate Market Update August 2025: Buyers Stay Active as Back-to-School Season Begins
A rare opportunity to own a piece of Sarasota design history—fully updated for today’s lifestyle.
Explore the latest Sarasota real estate market trends for Feb 23 – March 1, 2026. See updates on pending sales, closed transactions, price changes, and buyer activity … Read more
How to Prep for a Mortgage Before You Fall in Love With a House
Freezing = anything that requires a jacket we forgot we owned
Market Report for January 5-11,2025
I’d love to hear from you! Whether you’re buying, selling, or just exploring your options, I'm here to provide answers, insights, and the support you need. Contact me and start planning your next move.