Search

Leave a Message

Thank you for your message. I will be in touch with you shortly.

Browse Homes

A Tale of Two Housing Markets

Beth Helvey May 2, 2025

For a long time, the housing market was all sunshine for sellers. Homes were flying off the shelves, and buyers had to compete like crazy. But lately, things are starting to shift. Some areas are still super competitive for buyers, while others are seeing more homes sit on the market, giving buyers a bit more breathing room.

In other words, it’s a tale of two markets, and knowing which one you’re in makes a huge difference when you move.

What Is a Buyer’s Market vs. a Seller’s Market?

In a buyer’s market, there are a lot of homes for sale, and not as many people buying. With fewer buyers competing for these homes, that means they generally sit on the market longer, they might not sell for as much as they would in a seller’s market, and buyers have more room to negotiate.

On the flip side, in a seller’s market, there aren’t enough homes for sale for the number of buyers who are trying to purchase them. Homes sell faster, sellers often get multiple offers, and prices shoot higher because buyers are willing to pay more to win the home.

The Market Is Starting To Balance Out

For years, almost every market in the country was a strong seller’s market. That made it tough for buyers – especially first-timers. But now, things are shifting. According to Zillow, the national housing market is balancing out (see graph below):

a graph of a marketThe index used in this graph measures whether the national housing market is more of a seller’s market, buyer’s market, or neutral market – basically, whether it favors buyers, sellers, or if it’s not really swinging either way. Each month, the market is measured between 0 and 100. The closer to 100, the bigger the advantage sellers have.

The orange bars in the middle of the graph show the years when sellers had their strongest advantage, from 2020 to early 2022. But, as time has gone on, the market has become more balanced. It shifted from a strong seller’s market to a less intense one. And lately, it's been neutral more than anything else (that’s the gray bars on the right side of the graph). That means buyers are gaining some negotiating power again.

In a more balanced or neutral market, homes tend to stay on the market a little longer, bidding wars are less common, and sellers may need to make more concessions – like price reductions or helping with closing costs. That shift gives today’s buyers more opportunities and less competition than a couple of years ago.

Why Are Things Changing?

Inventory plays a big role. When there are more homes for sale, buyers have more options – and that cools down home price growth. As data from Realtor.com shows, the supply of available homes for sale isn’t growing at the same rate everywhere (see graph below):

a graph of a number of barsThis graph shows how inventory has changed compared to last year (blue bars) and compared to 2017–2019 (red bars) in different regions of the country.

The South and West regions of the U.S. have seen big jumps in housing inventory in the past year (that’s the blue on the right). Both are almost back to pre-pandemic levels. That’s why more buyer’s markets are popping up there.

But in the Northeast and Midwest, inventory is still very low compared to pre-pandemic (that’s why those red bars are so big). That means those areas are more likely to stay seller’s markets for now.

What This Means for You

Every local market is different. Even if the national headlines say one thing, your town (or even your neighborhood) could be telling a totally different story.

Knowing which type of market you’re in helps you make smarter decisions for your move. That’s why working with a local real estate agent is so important right now.

As Zillow says:

“Agents are experts on their local markets and can craft buying or selling strategies tailored to local market conditions.”

Agents understand the unique trends in your area and can help you make the best choices, whether you’re buying or selling. With their expert strategies, you can move no matter which way the market is leaning, because they know how to navigate various levels of buyer competition, how to find hidden gems locally, how to price a house right, how to negotiate based on who has more leverage, and more.

 

Bottom Line

If you're ready to make a move, or even just thinking about it, let’s connect. That way, you’ll have someone to help you understand our local market and create a game plan that works for you.

What’s one thing you’re curious about when it comes to the market in our area?

Florida Real Estate Blog

The Beauty and Resilience of Florida-Friendly Gardens

If You’re Selling Your Home Soon, Don’t Let the Word ‘Concession’ Scare You

9 Quaint Towns Straight Out of a Disney Movie

Sarasota’s Pro Soccer Team Is Leveling Up

How to Know if a “Delayed” or “Exclusive” Listing Is Right for You

What an Economic Slowdown Could Mean for the Housing Market

A Tale of Two Housing Markets

Mote Reports First Local Sea Turtle Nests of 2025 Season

May 1st is the First Official Day of Turtle Nest Season

Why Today’s Foreclosure Numbers Aren’t a Warning Sign

Paused Your Moving Plans? Here’s Why It’s Time To Hit Play Again

23 Biggest Interior Design Regrets, According to Influencers and Tastemakers

March 2025 Real Estate Market Report: Trends in Sarasota and Manatee Counties

Should I Buy a Home Now or Wait?

What You Can Do When Mortgage Rates Are a Moving Target

Does Your Current Home Fit Your Retirement Plans?

Pre-Approval Isn’t Commitment – It’s Clarity

Could Your Social Media Profile Be Hurting Your Chances of Getting a Mortgage?

These 8 Real Structures Inspired the Castles in Disney Films

Are You Saving Up To Buy a Home? Your Tax Refund Can Help

8 Ways to Size Up a Neighborhood Before You Buy a House There

5 Hidden Costs of House Hunting—Sneaky Little Expenses You Didn’t See Coming (But Totally Will)

Why You Don't Want To Skip Your Home Inspection

Seriously, Don't Skip It

The Truth About Newly Built Homes and Today’s Market

The #1 Thing Sellers Need To Know About Their Asking Price

Are “ADUs” Your Ticket to Smaller, More Affordable Housing?

Or to Start Your Income Property Journey?

Housing Market Panic?

Why You Shouldn’t Believe Every Headline (Or Chart) You See Online

Townhomes: A Smart Solution for Today’s First-Time Buyers

Selling Your First Home?

Here’s How Thinking Like a First-Time Buyer Can Help

A New Hotel Has Opened on Lido Key

Cirque St. Armands Beachside has replaced Lido Key’s Holiday Inn—and it’s a major upgrade.

Buyers Have More Negotiation Power

Here’s How To Use It

Why Pre-Approval Is More Important Than Ever

February 2025 Real Estate Market Report

Trends in Sarasota and Manatee Counties

Tiny Issues, Big Turn-Offs for Buyers

10 Small Fixes That Can Make or Break the Sale of Your Home

How Buying or Selling a Home Helps Your Local Economy

What You Need To Know About Homeowner’s Insurance

Planning Ahead: Putting Aside Money for Home Upkeep

What You Need to Know About Pre-Approval

Factors That Can Affect Your Preapproval

Is the Housing Market Starting To Balance Out?

It Is in Sarasota!

Selling Your Home? Here's Why More Deals Are Falling Apart

And How to Keep Yours on Track

Do You Know How Much Your Home Is Worth?

You May Want to Find Out.

Headed Back Into the Office?

You May Decide to Move

Sarasota Broke Rainfall Records

Sarasota just witnessed an extraordinary rainfall event yesterday, one for the record books.

A modern dining room with a black table and chairs. A vase with plants sits in the center of the table.
Ohana, on Longboat Key, Has Sold for $19.75 Million Cash

It’s probably part of why it fetched such a high price, setting a new record for tony Longboat Key.

Your Equity Could Make a Move Possible To Sarasota

Many homeowners looking to sell feel like they’re stuck between a rock and a hard place right now.

A modern kitchen with dark blue cabinets, a large marble countertop
Are You Ready For Hurricane Season in Sarasota?

Hurricane season started in Florida a few days ago and runs through November.

Work With Beth

I’d love to hear from you! Whether you’re buying, selling, or just exploring your options, I'm here to provide answers, insights, and the support you need. Contact me and start planning your next move.